So why not update the web site. Why do the holders of shares on the LSE have to go hunting on a Georgian website.
Why not tell shareholders about the interest payment and why not tell us the Georgian gov started the arbitration in 2017. Anyway, today’s news was very welcome and I personally think there’s a fighting chance we may still get something out of this.
the glaringly obvious omission is reference to star wars & the star wars universe
LSE Bugsy find. No translation yet. ZAZA on TV.
Imagine he talked about investment by Frontera in Georgia, energy independence, US support and maybe the issue of arbitration.
He looked quite well i must say, there really isn’t long to go now. Hope its not a case of April fools.
More meat on the bones from ZAZA. Great read, great find from Bugsy on LSE.
Translated from above
According to Zaza Mamulaishvili, executive director of the American energy company Frontera, they started creating problems for the state after 2013. Mamulashvili spoke about it in an exclusive interview with BMG.
The interview concerns the company’s operations in Georgia and the ongoing arbitration dispute in which the Oil and Gas Corporation is seeking $ 70 to $ 80 million in compensation from Fronetra. The dispute has been ongoing since 2017, with numerous statements by US and Senate and congressional officials. The Prime Minister’s letters to the congressmen of the government to the rule of law are calling. BMG- the exclusive interview
Mamulaishvili says that is not consistent with the information that the company arbitration process, “Oil and Gas Corporation” $ 3.5 billion dollars, demanded compensation and that the Co poratsiis by “deliberately” spread ipnormatsiaa.
- In what arbitration dispute are you currently involved with the Government of Georgia?
"First of all I want to emphasize that we are not in dispute, the state is in dispute with us. The contract is in the form of GOGC and the State Oil and Gas Agency. We have no violations under the contract, we have been operating in Georgia for over 20 years and have never violated any. The promise of this contract, however, is not only a matter of course bitrazho dispute began, but other disputes were initiated in the courts. I mean the courts of disputes. So for us it is not new. Since 2013 is different from the dispute against us.
Difficulties have virtually begun since 2013 in our work and operations. Prior to that, our business was running smoothly. There were no major issues that we could not solve.
Since 2013, after investing heavily in oil and gas, and especially in the supply of natural gas; As soon as we announced that we were going to move on to the next phase of work, it was then that there were major problems and practically a narrowing of our work, which resulted in several lawsuits being brought against us by the state. Subsequently, the Court of Arbitration sued and so on.
Because we have a very strong position on what the Georgian court is trying to do, this process has been going on for a long time, and the final decision has not yet been made. "
- According to the Oil and Gas Corporation’s 2018 report, You asked for $ 3.5 billion in compensation According to the Oil and Gas Corporation, you had a claim for this sum, but you later declined.
"This is not true. First of all, we did not sue the state, the opposite is the case. The state is suing us. I reiterate that the company does not charge the state $ 3.5 billion.
At $ 3.5 billion, that’s the amount we could potentially have earned if the government hadn’t prevented us from continuing operations. But this is not the amount or unaccountable income that the company claims against the state. The company has no claims against the state and has not initiated any lawsuits against it. "
- However, the GOGC 2018 Audit Report states exactly this number and the amount requested. The document is prepared by KPMG.
"KPMG probably got the information that was provided by the Oil and Gas Corporation. error, which intentionally or unintentionally is allowed.
but, unfortunately, they do not take any step gamosastsor In order to be. I want to tell you, it is very important that the company charges no state, no “Oil and Gas Corporation”, the court cases and the government began to GOGC- was against us. "
- You also talked about 2013, as you know, in 2013 you met the then Prime Minister Bidzina Ivanishvili. What was the meeting between you? - You have had meetings with other prime ministers in other years as well. Have you had any problems with these meetings?
"To be honest, we became Prime Minister in 2013. You know that we have been working in Georgia for over 20 years, for almost 22 years. We are the largest US investor in the Georgian energy sector. During this time, usually if the administration changes, We become leaders - whether the prime minister or the president We report on where we are and where our work is going.
In 2013, the purpose of this meeting was exactly the same as that of its predecessors. We introduced him to our work, our progress, our results, what we were planning, and by the way, we had a wonderful meeting with him [Bidzina Ivanishvili]. There were a few minor operational issues, exactly the administrative issues we dealt with, but there was a very good and productive meeting and interesting conversation.
This meeting did not reflect well on our work, unfortunately. Difficulties were exacerbated and aggravated, we came to the conclusion that the state had initiated several court cases in Georgia and crowned international arbitration dispute.
[Ivanishvili] was talking about the stockpile, the large stock of natural gas that we were looking at after a huge investment and huge amount of work, and talking about plans and a vision for what would be the next step and the next stage. How the company saw how the company would develop this enormous potential for Georgia. That was the content of this meeting.
- Ask about your statements about the stock of natural resources. The state has been skeptical of these statements and argued that there is no natural resource stock in Georgia. Based on what supporting documents did you make these statements?
"The volume of work is unprecedentedly large for Georgia, and not just for Georgia. Any region or country would be jealous of the amount of work and investment that we have invested. When was the end of those works? On the basis of which they say that there is no such stockpile of natural gas, I assure you that the stockpile is, and is very large,
a stockpile that can radically change Georgia’s economic development - for the sake of its prosperity.
How did we come to this conclusion? - This conclusion was made based on the results of the work we have been doing for years. This is seismic research, it is drilling, it is testing wells, it is a variety of so-called stimulation of extraction, oil and gas layers. As a result of this work, as soon as we submit all five of the world’s largest US companies that certify these supplies, they spend a year-and-a-half on each of these occasions to process this material and give us the first report in the history of Georgia. Face of Georgia ripe.
Such a thing had happened before. We are proud that due to the huge amount of work done and the huge investment, we have created tremendous potential for Georgia that no one knew about.
We believe that the next stage will be something that we thought in 2013 as well, but so far have not been given the opportunity to move to the next stage, which is the resource and the actual equity behavior. "
- What investment is related to the implementation?
"For example, the well-known Shah Deniz field, which extracts gas from the Caspian Sea, began 15-20 years ago, virtually 2000 years later. This field was discovered in 1952 after a huge amount of work in 1952. In order to conduct research, drill, develop the most correct and optimal techniques A. Drilling technology, conducting two-dimensional and three-dimensional seismic research, which we conducted for the first time in the history of Georgia, has never happened before, it needs to be sampled - 2,000, 3,000, 5,000 meters deep, you have to analyze these samples. A very technologically challenging process that has been around for the last 20 years Art busy. "
- Your Company’s latest audit report, which is posted on the website, is dated 6 months of 2018, and your Company’s revenue from natural resources sales was $ 1.8 million and total loss was $ 7 million. If you talk about stocks of this volume, then what is the loss? Is this due to the capability of the research work?
"Yes, our type of companies are oil exploration and extraction companies. This means that the company is engaged in both oil exploration and extraction activities. Usually, the exploration stage is a loss. Very intense investment and only after you find and find this stock and start taking advantage of it. Agis, is then transferred to the company has been profitable stage.
We at this stage are that this huge investment, as soon as we arrived at the stage that confirmed reserves certification is very large and well-known company and is now moving on to the next stage, after the fact, problems and The oppression of our work begins.
We were not allowed to do large-scale work as we thought. Still, we still continued drilling, but that certainly wasn’t the scale we wanted to capture. The reason for this was precisely this antagonistic attitude towards our work. "
- I would like to ask you about congressional statements. Many congressmen have made a statement in support of you, but the Georgian government has said that these statements were misleading; Can you tell us about your relationship with the House of Representatives or how they were interested in your company?
"Our interest in our problem has not happened yesterday and today, they are very familiar with our work and our company. Our work is very closely related to Georgia and other projects, closely related to Houston, different labs and people. So they know our business well and know The situation, even under the circumstances This is not the first time that supportive communications have been sent to Georgia without the support of congressmen and senators, as well as the administration in 2013 and 2014, we would not have been able to build the first gas pipeline in Georgian history built for the transportation of Georgian gas.
Had it not been for such strong support from senators and congressmen in 2014, we would not have been able, even though we were contractually contracted - to obtain a license to deliver the gas we had acquired in the pipeline we built. So, in 2013-2014, communication from Washington to our government and government was even more intense than it is now. So, this is not news, and such a tone and attitude and such concerns have been there for a long time - because of the circumstances in which the American company operates in Georgia.
As for the statement on lobbyists. A congressman cannot be a lobbyist. A lobbyist may be just a lobbyist, but the source of some information is that some are trying to prove that Frontera is paying any politician, this is not true.
Never, Frontera has not paid any politician any money. "
- If you can tell us in more detail what the state is currently looking for? What is the point of this dispute?
" , Although we can still work on the ground for many more years - which is an existing contract is identified.
They want to prematurely stop our this agreement and ask us by about $ 80 million dollars, as if we are in the state have the money to pay, which is also not true. "
- the dispute by $ 80 million dollars to you by natural gas proceeds from the sale Distribution or any other fee s?
"different types kalkualatsia have made that quite clear to us, but given the fact that the process is currently in progress, I will not go into details. However, the fact that the company owes any kind of debt to the state must have been paid and not received - it is not true. "
- Ask about the payroll debt you have accumulated in Georgia. How long has the extraction work been suspended and how much debt do you owe to the employees?
"Some say 11 months, some say 14 months, some say 8 months - none of these figures are correct. There is some debt to some employees for a few months. The
company was ready to sue the state without a lawsuit showing a very bad angle. Georgia in terms of investment attractiveness.
As if the government had agreed to all of this, negotiations have been going on intensively for the last 4 months, perhaps even more so, even when we were negotiating with the state, we did not ask those employees to resign in the hope that we would sign the agreement and continue our usual routine.
But at the last moment, the state refused to agree. Because of this expectation, when we didn’t ask employees, we owed them debt.
Also, the state does not pay the VAT we collected. It must compensate for the paid VAT, which is already several million.
Because of all this [the employees] have created this situation. However, we have long been offering our employees the option to repay the debt they have for several months. But here, too, in some cases, the state, in some cases, other people associated with the government, are announcing these people and calling for action.
still have not signed up for this staff to the agreement, which resulted in the need to start for several months to make payments, but the Ministry of Economy and some MPs to encourage them not to do that. "
- 2019 January your company removed the London Stock Exchange’s Alternative funding from the market. The reason What happened?
"It has its own procedure for determining what conditions there are for the company to be traded on the stock exchange.
We were, by the way, the first company to put a Georgian project on the stock market for the first time in Georgia’s history, even when the stock market didn’t know Georgia. Very successful listing that got in the way paved many other Georgian companies, and I’m proud of that.
We - the public company we were in 15 years. In these conditions, when the state is not only promoting, but also harmful actions carried out in very many years, just like a lost cause for the stock market presence. So the count, the more appropriate It would be that as a private equity society oebas continue our work. Then we’ll see. "
- The decision of the Arbitration Court is already approaching. What are your expectations about Verdict?
"The court hearings were held in London, awaiting a ruling. We do not know when. We expect to be positive in that we do not have, and we know that we have never had nearly $ 70- $ 80 million in debt to the state and we know the terms of the contract have not been violated, so We are optimistic, we hope and believe it is Georgia will continue to work and move in the right moment, when not only the company, but also for the very large benefits will be discovered by our oil and gas resource potential. "
Thanks to Bugsy for his research and translation efforts, enormously appreciated as usual, and our longest serving super sleuther. Another pint added to his ‘I O U list’.
People grumble about Zaza not talking to shareholders, but with these TV and newspaper interviews, isn’t he indirectly talking to us? Plus he is in the public eye. So, while we are in the midst of multiple legal battles, I guess his attention is to put those fires out first, and that I can appreciate.
So what about the interview? Well, now that the arbitration is over, I guess he feels he can speak more freely about the dispute with the State. I did say in one of my previous posts that since the Dream Party came to power in October 2012, FRR has been on the back foot. It seems the whole development phase in B12 has been derailed by Ivanishvili as demonstrated by the multiple spats with Khaka Kaladze when he was the Minister for Energy. Instead of celebrating a world class gas discovery on the doorstep of Europe, FRR was and continues to be ridiculed from the Georgians. Had there been just some public support from some local politicians, I think there would have a massive interest and financial investment inflows from Super Majors.
Anyway, seems the crux of the dispute is $70-80m that the State feels it is owed under the profit sharing agreement. Well, I can tell you, FRR has never generated $70-80m in total revenues in the last 7 years let alone profits, so I don’t know where this number has come from.
Also very interesting comments on the plight of unpaid workers, and again as we suspected, it seems no-good politicians were behind these public demonstrations; pawns in a political game.
So, now we know how deep this rabbit hole goes, for what, a barren piece of land? Yeah right! The Georgians are prepared to risk relations with the US over this, which means Ivanishvili is already Russia aligned but pretending to West-facing. Hoodwinkers at the grandest level. Having said all that, most probably Dream Party will get re-elected in October’s elections given the disarray of the opposition parties.
Still feeling uncertain about the arbitration decision - kinda half empty glass.
Could go either way SB, the gov allegedly spent 6m on the case so that may suggest they were perhaps not in a strong position to begin with. Anyway April isn’t that far off.
Agreed Fozz, they’ve (allegedly) spent $6m on this arbitration. Plus, Zaza is now suggesting there has been numerous other court cases pursued in Georgia. This regime has been toxic for a lot of foreign companies and it about someone tried to pull the veil down. Senator Olson called Ivanishvili a puppet for Putin (“…there it’s out in the open now”).
Also consider that the Ukraine president (zelensky) has visited Washington yet Ivanishvili who was Georgia’s PM and now Chairman of the ruling party has not visited since his Party Power came to power in 2012 - not a strong indicator of wanting close ties with the US; instead he has been sending his second tier cronies.
Anyway whichever way the arbitration goes, it is good to see Zaza not hiding or backing off. In the TV interview, he was proudly sitting side-by-side by the strategically positioned Frontera Resources flag.
Thanks to Bugs from the LSE, folks thought us Frontera investors were crazy conspiracy theorists but there you have it…
My glass is now starting to become half full SB, assuming the arbitration goes our way i think Frontera could have a future. The only sticking point i see is if there’s only 7 years left on the license but everything can be overcome with the right incentive and political pressure.
6 weeks till April.
Past president now commenting, this is coming to a head quite quickly.
He rarely uses Twitter by the looks of things his last tweet prior to this one was dec 18 so he only tweets when something serious is needs addressing
Well Fozz - that was an astonishing interview by Ivanishvili’s predecessor, Mikhel Saakashvili. And being the previous PM of Georgia, this information has a lot of credence. It also fills in a lot of gaps as to why FRR has suffered so much since 2013 [notably the public spat with Kaladze who was then the Minister of Energy].
So the question is, how deep does this rabbit hole goes? Well, apparently, all the way to the Kremlin. Georgia is now being run by a proxy of Putin. Plus, there has been no direct discussions with Russia about occupied lands of South Ossetia and Abkhazia. Nothing since 2012.
Why risk the wrath of US and [may be] EU by fighting over B12, when a company has invested US$500M in your country?
Plus we always wondered how a small AIM company like FRR could garner so such strong support in the US, and now we its been revealed its down to Ted Cruz.
Anyway, terribly dirty politics, and a bad advertisement for Georgia as a foreign investment.
As far as the arbitration is concerned, I am still half empty…
Yep, the interview confirms what we all suspected.
At least there’s something in the glass SB so there’s Hope. It takes a lot for an arbitration to rule against a sovereign nation but it wouldn’t surprise me if the gogc just gave it a go on the assumption FRR would go bankrupt and i think we all suspect who has been funding the gogc now. Obviously they underestimated Zaza and Steve.
My glass is now half full…never underestimate our overseas cousins.
This really is getting serious now:-
Kicking off big time!!!
Fozz, must admit things are looking good for FRR with the sizeable support in the US and in Georgia, but best to keep expectations in check until there is news on the Arbitration. With these Russian politicians, they can go very low e.g. shooting down of the Malaysian Airline, election interference in the US, indiscriminate bombing of civilians in Syria, the poisonings in the UK, the list goes on & on. No wonder Dracula Ivanishvili sheet scared of Kremlin.