It looks like you are using an older browser that is unsupported by our website. To get the best experience, you will need to update your browser. Find out how to update your browser

Government mulling worker pensions that mimic final salary

Rachel Lacey unpacks fresh proposals to guide workers into pensions that deliver a reliable retirement income.

18th November 2026 13:44

by Rachel Lacey from interactive investor

Share on

Smiling private sector worker

There’s currently a gaping chasm in workplace pension provision; you’ll either retire with a pot you’ll need to manage yourself, with a value that’s based on your contributions and investment performance or, if you work in the public sector, you’ll get a guaranteed income for life that’s based on your earnings.

The former could run out, the latter can’t.

Now, the government is attempting to bridge that gap by launching a consultation into “guided retirement” – a new pathway intended to deliver a reliable income for life to 17 million private sector workers, currently in defined contribution (DC) schemes.

Guided retirement

Announcing the initiative, Torsten Bell, minister for pensions, said people in the private sector deserved a better deal: “We are resurrecting proper pensions for private sectors workers, guaranteeing them the option of an income that lasts throughout retirement and, in many cases, protection against the rising cost of living - things public sector workers take for granted.”

“We are going to give pensions back to the people who are working hard and saving for their retirement.”

The proposals are part of a wider consultation on Retirement Collective Pension Schemes (RCPS). This would be a new type of default pension fund within workplace pensions, that pool risk to deliver members stable income in retirement, without the need to choose a new product in the open market at the start of their retirement.

There isn’t much detail on what this would look like, but the thinking is that it would seek to provide a target retirement income that could be adjusted according to how investments perform.

To access guided retirement, your savings would need to be invested in a RCPS pot, but members wouldn’t be compelled to follow the guided retirement route.

For any saver who is worried about outliving their savings, the proposals may well be welcomed. It should provide reassurance to people who don’t want to manage their money themselves.

But taking this easy default option could come at a price and undermine the efforts savers have made to prepare for retirement.

Is it possible to bridge the pensions gap?

While Bell talks about resurrecting the “pension” for private sector workers and closing the gap between defined benefit and defined contribution pensions, there’s a telling word missing from the proposals and that’s “guarantee”.

With a defined benefit (DB) pension, income is guaranteed not just to last for life, but to be paid at a pre-determined rate based on the members’ earnings, their length of service and the accrual rate of the scheme. That means the risk is borne by the employer – there shouldn’t be any unpleasant surprises for individuals.

And while longevity protection will be a core element of guided retirement, that could mean there’s a trade-off on income. Schemes will have the ability to change income based on the performance of the fund’s underlying investments.

Some commentators have also questioned whether risk pooling could mean that younger generations end up subsidising the scheme’s older members.

As such, there’s a real risk that savers will think that they are getting a pension that rivals those of peers in the private sector and could end up disappointed with the income it actually delivers. Importantly, if savers change their minds, they’ll only be able to do so in the first 12 months, thereafter it’s expected they will be locked in.

Rather than being a pension that mimics public sector pensions, guided retirement will just be another income option to add to the existing list – and a confusing one at that.

Is another income pathway needed?

For those savers who want lifelong income, that’s already available in the form of an annuity.

Annuities provide a guaranteed income for life in exchange for some or all of your pension – the amount you get is linked to prevailing interest rates at the time of your purchase, your age and state of health.

The younger and healthier you are – that is the longer you’re expected to live – the less you’ll get.

But while sales of these policies plummeted when the pension freedoms were introduced in 2015 and flexi-access drawdown became a more viable option – they’re picking up again as rising interest rates have substantially increased the income they can provide.

The catch is that while you can set up policies that will pay an income to your partner if you die first, there’s no pot of income to pass on to loved ones.

Annuities are insurance products that rely on a “mortality cross-subsidy” to work, with funds from those who die earlier than anticipated funding the retirements of those who outlive underwriters’ expectations.

But in choosing a traditional annuity at least - rather than the new pathway - savers have the freedom to shop around for the highest income. And, if their lifestyle or health status means that they are likely to have a reduced life expectancy as a result, then they’ll get a higher payment with an enhanced annuity.

The bigger issue though, is that while annuities might be more popular than they were, data from the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) shows that they simply don’t appeal to lots of retirees.

When it looked at how pots valued over £30,000 were accessed the first time – just 16% used an annuity. Two-thirds (67%) chose flexibility over security with pension drawdown.

Of course, some of those people might go on to buy an annuity at a later date (when they are likely to get a higher income or they start to prioritise security), but at the start of retirement, there’s an understandable desire to keep income options open.

Pension drawdown lets you take as much or as little out of your pension as you want. And as your funds remain invested, there’s the potential to benefit from further stock market growth. Importantly, any remaining funds when you die can be passed down to the loved ones of your choice.

The drawback is that you need to think carefully about where you invest your pension and how much you withdraw, to ensure you don’t outlive your savings.

Complex decisions

The government says that retirees shouldn’t have to make such complex decisions or become investment experts overnight.

Nobody would argue against that. Pensions are highly complicated, as is retirement income planning.

But is the answer to the problem another, at this moment quite vague, pathway?

Within the framework of the pension freedoms there are already multiple options and, by using a “pick and mix” approach, it’s possible to structure your retirement income in a way that works for you – striking the necessary balance between flexibility and peace of mind.

The state pension already provides retirees with a base level of guaranteed income and it’s possible to buy some more with an annuity. You can then keep some funds in drawdown for access to lump sums as and when needed.

Retirement changes

What has perhaps been missing from the wider conversation so far, is the fact that it’s not just pensions that have changed in recent decades. Retirement has changed too – the wind down from work is often more gradual and when it does come, retirees naturally want to make the most of those years.

“Resurrecting” the pension with a one-size-doesn’t-fit-all default plan shouldn’t also force us to resurrect an old-fashioned retirement, marked with a carriage clock on your last day of work and limited financial flexibility. Retirees need income solutions that can be tailored to their needs and lifestyle.

There aren’t easy answers, but rather than attempting to replicate final salary pension income, without DB funding, shouldn’t the focus instead be on helping retirees to make the most of the current system?

Better pensions education should be an important part of that process, but potentially even more important than that, we also need affordable advice – not just generic guidance.

The government is correct that the pension freedoms can put retirees at risk, but discouraging them from using that flexibility full stop won’t necessarily give them a good deal either.

These articles are provided for information purposes only.  Occasionally, an opinion about whether to buy or sell a specific investment may be provided by third parties.  The content is not intended to be a personal recommendation to buy or sell any financial instrument or product, or to adopt any investment strategy as it is not provided based on an assessment of your investing knowledge and experience, your financial situation or your investment objectives. The value of your investments, and the income derived from them, may go down as well as up. You may not get back all the money that you invest. The investments referred to in this article may not be suitable for all investors, and if in doubt, an investor should seek advice from a qualified investment adviser.

Full performance can be found on the company or index summary page on the interactive investor website. Simply click on the company's or index name highlighted in the article.

Related Categories

    Pensions, SIPPs & retirementEditors' picks

Get more news and expert articles direct to your inbox